Ron Shevlin, the Forrester alum who blogs at Marketing ROI and occasionally at NetBanker (posts here), has been on a roll recently with a number of thought-provoking posts that take on the conventional wisdom we hear in meetings, press releases, and other soundbites picked up by the press.

Earlier this month, Ron challenged some of the statements made in the press implying that the downfall of NetBank was caused by its online delivery strategies (here). That initial post led to an interesting discussion culminating in this gem (here) where he takes on the whole notion that banks MUST have branches to acquire new accounts, concluding (words in parenthesis are my additions to show context):

"The inability of the Internet to supplant the branch as the acquisition channel of choice (so far) has very little to do with the inherent superiority of the branch, and everything to do with the (current) inferiority of the online channel." 

And my favorite, this zinger:

In effect, bank branches are just big, expensive security blankets.

Inspired by his post, I've come up with what I'll call the "5 Habits of Inefficient Delivery" (see note 1). 

Habit #1: Customers go to branches to solve service problems.

Expensive solution: Build more multi-million dollar branches to house expensive service reps to sooth frustrated customers. 

Better solutions: (A) Improve the product/service so there are fewer problems; (B) Solve customer problems online in near real-time, not "within 24 to 48 hours"; (C) Empower online support reps to solve problems without forcing the customer to make an hour-long trek to a branch.

Habit #2: Customers go to branches to apply for new accounts.

Expensive solution: Build more multi-million dollar branches and staff them with well-compensated sales agents to transcribe applications hand-delivered by customers.

Better solutions: (A) Develop a killer online sales process that helps customers choose the right option; (B) Provide a user-friendly application with 24/7 online support and solid guarantees. 

Habit #3: Customers feel more comfortable with a bank that has a large branch presence.

Expensive solution: Build more multi-million dollar branches or what Ron calls, "big, expensive security blankets."

Better solutions: (A) Trust your customers and treat them right at every opportunity, and they'll remain loyal no matter how many branches you operate; (B) Keep prices competitive, i.e., no more 10 basis points of interest for a savings account (see here). 

Habit #4: Customers like to use the branch to deposit paper checks.

Expensive solution: Build more multimillion-dollar branches that serve as human-powered ATMs.

Better solution: Until paper checks disappear, use remote-deposit capture, envelope-free (image) ATMs, and instant credit for mailed deposits such as Pennsylvania School Employees Credit Union's (PSECU) Upost@Home (previous coverage here) (see note 2).

Habit #5: Customers go to branches because they are there.

Expensive solution: Build more multimillion-dollar branches to stay within a few minutes' drive or walk for most of your customers

Better solution: Make the online and telephone customer experience so phenomenal and complete that no one misses the branches as they close and consolidate

Notes:

1. For more information, see Online Banking Report, "The Demise of the Branch"

2. On a related note, see PSECU's "Go Branchless" campaign (here)