« Tech Credit Union, Wachovia Create First iPhone Buttons | Main | Revolution Money Adds Facebook App for P2P Payments, Pays $25 Bonus »

Discovering the Social Economy at Net.Finance

By William Azaroff on January 27, 2008 9:16 AM | Comments (17)

Last week’s Net.Finance conference entitled Online Innovations in Financial Services Marketing brought thought leaders together in New York to examine trends and breakthroughs in the world of banking.

For me, there was one clear take away: The new social tools that allow people to connect with each other online are ushering in a new economy.

We are moving into a social economy, where collaboration and participation between and among consumers will sway their choices more than marketing messages do. Those companies that enable social participation, add value to people’s lives and create authentic experiences for their customers will lead in this new economy. There were other topics discussed, but this theme kept creeping into the presentations and conversations in a way I had never before encountered. I’m going to narrow in on this one theme, which ran throughout the two days of the conference, and I apologize to those companies and speakers I’m not highlighting here.

ING DirectJurie Pieterse – ING Direct
Jurie outlined several of the key ways that ING is handling the power of its marketing and messaging to consumers by opening up its brand to customer participation. It is clear from ING’s early experimentation that it has a brand with strong emotional appeal and resonance. The bank opens the doors to people who engage with the brand to create photos, videos and prose about how their relationship with ING helps them manage their money.

Jurie explained that when they delivered the prizes in their user-generated content contests, which ranged from $1,000 to $15,000, most winners said that they entered the contests more from a sense of fun and participation than for the money. After this initial experimenting, ING will begin to examine the data to determine if these contest entrants are more loyal and profitable than less engaged customers. I would bet my Electric Orange account they are.

Prosper.comChris Larsen Prosper
It is fascinating to watch Prosper evolve their model. Chris spoke at length about the importance of social capital to improving its default rates. The idea is that people who have peer pressure built into their borrowing habits will pay back at a better rate than they do to traditional financial institutions.

Prosper has found that people who receive at least one of bid from friends or family have significantly lower default rates than those who only borrow from strangers. By leveraging this social capital, the entire community acts more honestly, even if lending to friends and family is a small part of the overall equation.

WesabeJason KnightWesabe
Jason sees Wesabe as a community of interest focused on money. By allowing members to tag their financial transactions and share whatever information they choose with the greater community, they create a collective intelligence I find very exciting. I see them as the long tail of financial advice. People discuss better ways to use their money, from smarter investing habits to buying better cuts of meat. All of this collective intelligence fuels a social economy where people rule their situation by having a much healthier relationship to the way they spend their money.

Verity Credit UnionShari StormVerity Credit Union
Shari oversaw the creation of the first “bank” blog, which Verity started in 2004. She has strong information and advice to other FIs considering jumping into the world of blogging. It is clear that the blog is an excellent way to humanize the company and engage with their community in an honest and transparent way.

TradeKingThomas A. Desmond TradeKing
I was blown away by TradeKing, a company I had not heard of before. Their marriage of social tools inseparable from their trading platform is perhaps the very best example of social media being used strategically by a company that I have seen.

They have baked community aspects into everything that happens on their site, so, if traders opt in to the community, they can learn from each other based on their actual trading results (similar to Zecco.com, below)

VZirgin MoneyAsheesh AdvaniVirgin Money
It took me a minute to wrap my head around Virgin Money’s model, but once I got it, I was hooked. Many people who buy houses get side loans from friends and family to make a bigger downpayment. Same with student loans, or with unsecured personal or business loans. Virgin creates a model around this kind of lending, so both sides can take advantage of the tax benefits available via a documented lending relationship. It creates excellent flexibility, because if a borrower needs to skip payments, the lender can adjust the loan accordingly. The loan can always be turned into a gift at a later date. This takes a part of the social economy which was underground and unseen, and brings it above board, recognizing it as an important part of the overall economy.

Zecco.comGabriel DalportoZecco.com
Zecco and TradeKing's models have many similarities (one exception being that Zecco offers 10 free trades each month). Community features are built right into the tools making it easy to track individual investors within the community. That allows the higher performers to gain a following and for newcomers to learn from the veterans. Like TradeKing, Zecco allows community menbers to see the actual trading results and portfolio holding of members (that have opted in), adding an enormous amount of credibilty to discussions about individual stocks and trading strategies.

Summary
It feels more and more to me that we’re at a turning point. I admit that these innovations are small, just barely bubbling up to the surface. But I believe these examples of companies quietly tapping into unmet needs provide a model of the future.

Anyone working at a financial institution who wants to understand the potential opportunities and threats coming our way should watch these companies and understand their models. If my experience is any indication, the social economy will begin to trickle into your FI's strategies and executive discussions and those who best understand these concepts can help inform, influence and shape the outcome.

William Azaroff is the Interactive Marketing & Channel Manager at Vancity where he develops interactive marketing initiatives, and pioneered ChangeEverything.ca, the groundbreaking change-themed online community. William builds on a decade of experience at digital agencies in Vancouver, Seattle and Los Angeles driving strategy, extending brands to the Web and building relationships for companies in several verticals, including Honda, Disney, Intuit Canada and the Government of BC. He discusses trends and noteworthy achievements in social media at his blog: azaroff.com/blog.

Comments (17)

Most Recent Posts:

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.netbanker.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-t.cgi/1787

17 Comments

William, Great catching up with you, Shari, and Trey, and meeting Jim, Sloan, Tracy, and Brian in Manhattan.

Thanks for this recap, and sharing with us this new commonality in the latest with financial innovations. These innovations may seem small, but really they are already huge. I don't know if Chris Larson talked about Prosper's growth rate, but it's staggering.

(At their current rate, later this year, Prosper's membership would make them the third largest CU in the U.S. if they were a CU.... and they've only been in existence for two years. Wow.)

With that kind of meteoric growth, anything they now do has instant cred.

Hi Morriss. Interesting comparison to a Credit Union membership. I never thought of it that way.

Chris Larsen mention the latest stats for Prosper:
-2 years in business
-560,000 users
-$113MM in loan volume

I was utterly fascinated by what he had to say, and this was the third time I've heard him speak. Does that make me a groupie?

Great recap William. Excellent work.

Great post William - sounds like a fascinating conference; interesting to hear the innovative social experiments FIs are engaging in.

Cheers,

Jeremy

Thanks all. I have been pondering the Social Economy for a few months now, and to see it start to bubble up as a topic in session after session was very powerful and inspiring. I look forward to the evolution of this concept, to see where it goes.

Hi William,
Thank you for sharing your thoughts with the group again. It was a pleasure working with you - as always! We have been receiving positive feedback about Online Innovations so I do hope we helped fuel more interest and excitement for financial services to evaluate and experiment on how social tools can really connect people, build communities and improve customer relationships. See you at Net.Finance in a few months!

I wanted to add that William Azaroff himself gave an outstanding presentation on blogging and how to handle situations where a negative item has been posted about your FI on an individual's blog.

And besides the content, his slides were just awesome...I had serious powerpoint envy!

Thanks for the writeup, William.

I agree we are at a turning point, and it’s exciting to have Zecco be part of this revolution in online investing. If you ever have questions about what we’re doing at Zecco and the direction we’re headed, feel free to get in touch with me. It’s easy to find me in our community at ZeccoShare.

Hey William - Thanks much for such a great summary. I'm very envious of those who could make it to the conference, but appreciate the recap. Now if I can just find someone to recap what was obviously an excellent presentation by yourself I'll be all set!

: )

@Gabe - I have really enjoyed seeing you present about your company twice now. It's an amazing story, one that shifts the focus from the investment house to the investors. Very powerful stuff.

@Ted - I couldn't bring myself to write about my own presentation. I'll leave that to others. I was extremely pleased with how it went.

William, great summary. I will pass around here. BTW, can I get a copy of your slides?

Thanks Ed. The presentation is huge, so I can't email it. I'll touch base with you offline...

William,

Excellent synopsis and I second Jim's comments on your presentation as well. This was the first time I've heard many of the speakers and they provided me with some really terrific ideas. The social networking concept is challenging to put in a business context, but these folks really seem to "get it". I hope I can help my organization get it too.

Hi Kevin, thanks for your comment. Do you think showing Zecco and TradeKing to the execs at ML will get a reaction? Will it inspire, scare, shed light, fall on deaf ears?

It's so much harder to change course to include community features, rather than bake them in from the start.

Great meeting you in NY.

@William: a great post. Thanks for this report. J'aurai aimé participer à cette conférence...

Thanks for the good article. The author points to a number of factors that will help move company for the next phase of the company's development.
If you are interested in balanced scorecard metrics in business, check this web-site to learn more about Metrics

http://www.business-development-metrics.com

Leave a comment

Sponsors

Yodlee wesabe


Sponsored Links

Events

  • FinovateSpring 2010 -- Dozens of handpicked fintech companies demoing their newest innovations in the entrepreneurial hotbed of San Francisco. 7 minutes each on stage to demo. No slides. A single value-packed day on 5/11/2010. Get your early-bird ticket today!

  • FinovateFall 2010 -- Dozens of handpicked fintech companies showcasing their latest & greatest in the financial capital of the world -- NYC. 7 minutes each on stage to demo. No slides. A single value-packed day on 10/05/2010. Get your early-bird ticket today!

Research

  • NEW! Making the Case for Person-to-Person Payments: Does mobility provide the tipping point for bank-branded P2P? - Find out more
  • NEW! Attracting Small Businesses with Online & Mobile Banking: Underserved segment is prime candidate for alt-delivery - Find out more
  • 2010 Guide to Online & Mobile Banking Products, Pricing & Strategy: Your roadmap for business planning - Find out more
  • Improving Online Account Opening ROI: Ten strategies to increase online application conversion rates - Find out more
  • Connecting to Customers with Twitter: The comprehensive guide to Twitter for financial institutions - Find out more
  • Selling behind the Password: Leveraging the marketing potential within online banking - Find out more
  • New Techniques in Secure Online Finance: Sandboxing, keyboard encryption, and real-time mobile integration could lock in more online customers- Find out more

Products & Services

  • Online Banking Services: Compare online banking services and savings rates from the leading financial institutions at Credit.com.

 

   

RSS Subscribe via RSS
RSS Subscribe to Comments



Email:


@NetBanker Twitter Feed



See all @NetBanker tweets

Most Recent Comments


thebankwatch.com commented on Citibank, Microsoft Join Forces with Bundle, a Personal Finance Site with a Data Bent

Jim Bruene commented on What Does the New Apple iPad Mean for Banking?

Jean-Christophe Capelli commented on FinovateSpring's Lowest Ticket Prices Expire in 3 Days!

Jim Bruene commented on Blippy Demonstrates the Power of Real-Time Streaming of Financial Transaction Data

Jeffry Pilcher commented on Syphr Launches Credit and Loan Info Site, MoreThanACreditReport.com

Structured Settlement commented on Banks Help Fundraising Efforts for Haiti Relief