Impressive Gains for Online Brokerages
By Jim Bruene on May 16, 2000 9:55 PM | 0 Comments
Online trading continued to improve on its popularity accounting for 48% of all retail trades in the second half of 1999, up from 37% in the first half of the year (Table 8).The major online brokerages chalked up impressive gains in account and asset growth during first quarter. Schwab retains the number one position in total assets and trading activity, while Fidelity maintained its number one position in total number of accounts (Table 4). In February, Ameritrade.com combined with its onmoney.com unit overtook E*Trade as the busiest online brokerage site. During April, 3.4 million visitors came to Ameritrade/OnMoney, placing the brokerage in fifth place among all financial services companies . Only X.com, NextCard, Intuit, and Providian had more traffic.
Table 4
Largest Online Brokersthousands of active online accounts
Sources: Piper Jaffray Inc. 4/2000, and individual companies www.ecinvestor.com , Stephen Franco is contact at Piper Jaffray, (415) 984-4646; The data represents all online trades in North America. It does not include automated telephone trades or trades placed with a human broker; historical numbers have been adjusted, as new data became available. 1Growth in “OTHER” is primarily from MSDW and Webstreet, which have not released first quarter numbers.
Table 5
Web Traffic at Top 16 Brokerage Sitesunique monthly visitors (thousands)
Source: PC Data Online ; Gomez Advisors Spring 2000 Broker Scorecard, rank among 56 providers <gomez.com>; 1Includes etradebank.com, telebank.com telebankonline.com ; n.r.=not rated
Table 6
Online Brokerage Forecastsmillions of active online accounts and households**
Source: companies 11998 total; 2April 1999; 3CAGR = 22% for accounts, 39% for households
Most analysts predict continued growth in the penetration of online investing and investment research within the population as a whole. For example, eMarketer, consolidating views from a number of financial services researchers, predicts that the penetration rate of online trading will grow from 6.2% today to 11% in 2002, and the percentage doing online investment research will grow from 28% of online users today to 38% (Table 7). In 1999, Forrester predicted that this year approximately 50% of retail equity and mutual fund trades would occur online (Table 8).
Table 7
Active Traders vs. Researchersmillions of online accounts**
Source: eMarketer, eFinancial Services Report, 12/99 www.estats.com
Table 8
Percentage of Retail Orders Received Online
| Type of Investment |
1998 |
2000 |
CAGR |
| Equities |
19.5% |
48.3% |
57% |
| Mutual Funds |
19.8% |
48.3% |
56% |
| Fixed Income |
1.4% |
13.3% |
210% |
| Foreign Exchange |
0% |
2.7% |
n/a |
| Commodities |
0% |
2.3% |
n/a |
Source: Forrester, 1999
Onmoney.com is drawing 1.6 million unique users per month, but only 220,000 have stayed long enough to register; 40,000 of those have signed up for account aggregation from VerticalOne. In our view, the home page could use less noise and more focus.
